Egyptian blogger reviled for being pro-Israel

RNW, 12 January 2012, by Jannie Schipper

(Photo: Maikel Nabil)

               

The Egyptian blogger Maikel Nabil Sanad was one of the first people to be criticized by the military government following the fall of President Mubarak. He has been imprisoned since March 2011. While international demands for his release get ever louder, in Egypt he is subjected to widespread abuse, mostly in the form of insults and accusations. So what has he done?

There are several important differences between Maikel Nabil and other demonstrators: firstly he has been critical of the army since early 2011, when almost everyone else was still cheering the role of the army during the uprising. And secondly, the most significant differences: he is an atheist and he wants peace with Israel.

"How strange that there are people who defend Maikel Nabil," said a girl on a blog. "Has even betrayal become a personal freedom?" That touches on a fundamental question: If someone has an opinion which is totally opposed to the majority, does that mean he has less rights? That he should be put in prison by a military court and sentenced without a fair trial, abused and treated as a madman?

Critical articles

In a photo, the blogger is seen wearing a striped shirt and with a sign in his hand: "The people don't want the military to hijack the revolution." It could have been a random protester in Tahrir Square; protesters in Cairo have been chanting such slogans in recent weeks. But Maikel Nabil Sanad was already doing that much earlier. During and after the revolution of January 2011 he continued writing articles critical of the military on his blog, having previously refused military service. Following his last piece, entitled "Army and people were never united", the military took him from his home on 28 March 2011.

In April a military court sentenced Nabil to three years in prison, a penalty that was reduced to two years in December. He went on hunger strike for four months and lived on fruit juice and milk until he ended his hunger strike on New Year's Eve.

Amnesty International

There was a major international outcry: Media watchdog Reporters Without Borders sent an open letter to the UN, Amnesty International drew attention to the case, and support came from all over the world. In the Netherlands the Egyptian blogger was, among other things, given the approval of Ronny Naftaniel, director of the Centre for Information and Documentation on Israel.

Doesn't such a clear endorsement from a pro-Israeli organisation work against Maikel Nabil's best interests? "I've considered that," says Mr Naftaniel. "He's not popular because of his views, that's clear. But he himself has said that my support is important. His views on Israel are part of his view of life. "

Symbol

In Egypt, a group of activists have organized demonstrations for the release of Maikel Nabil. To them, his imprisonment symbolises the plight of almost 12,000 Egyptian citizens who have had to face a military tribunal since the fall of Mubarak.

"The views of Maikel have certainly influenced the opinion of the people," says his brother Mark, "but they understand that words are one thing, and condemning people for their opinion is something else." Yet it seems that for many people his controversial views are sufficient reason to deny him any rights. He doesn't get the approval of many ordinary Egyptians. "He doesn't deserve jail, but the death penalty," is one of the comments on a YouTube video from Elmokhalestv that promises to show "the truth about Maikel Nabil".

Israeli friends

It is a truth that the blogger has never concealed: he favours peace with Israel. He refused military service because, amongst other things, he didn't want to fight Israeli soldiers who were also conscripts. He also asked his 'Israeli friends' to support the Egyptian revolution, and he even translated part of his website into Hebrew.

Egyptian state media seized on his pro-Israeli statements as a reason to portray a demonstration in his support as a 'Zionist march'. Even in prison he encounters hostility. At Nabil's request, human rights lawyer Amir Salem recently submitted a complaint after a fellow prisoner attacked him and got the support of prison staff.

"A revolutionary, atheist pro-Israeli critic of the army made him the perfect candidate to pave the road of oppression against bloggers, which ensured that their sentencing would be met with minimum opposition from the public," writes blogger Mina Naguib. What applies to Nabil also seems to apply to a lesser extent to other bloggers with different points of view: when someone who is convicted turns out to be an atheist or makes too liberal statements, public support is limited.

No concessions

Nabil shows no willingness to make concessions. He makes no attempt to disguise his radical vision for Egypt in the hope of more lenient treatment. "Maikel will soften his views when he is mistaken, but as long as he thinks he's right, he's free to say whatever he wants," says his brother Mark.

Related Articles:

Court upholds law banning Palestinian spouses from living in Israel

Israeli Arabs enter Jewish classrooms

"The End of History" – Nov 20, 2010 (Kryon channelled by Lee Carroll)

(Subjects: Abraham, Isaac, Ishmael, Muhammad, Jesus, God, Jews, Arabs, EU, US, Israel, Iran, Russia, Africa, South America, Global Unity,..... etc.) (Text version)

"If an Arab and a Jew can look at one another and see the Akashic lineage and see the one family, there is hope. If they can see that their differences no longer require that they kill one another, then there is a beginning of a change in history. And that's what is happening now. All of humanity, no matter what the spiritual belief, has been guilty of falling into the historic trap of separating instead of unifying. Now it's starting to change. There's a shift happening."